Arnold Schoenberg: Evolution from Tonality

Introduction

Arnold Schoenberg, a pioneering composer of the 20th century, underwent a revolutionary transformation in his musical style, shifting from traditional tonality to groundbreaking atonality. This article explores the evolution of Schoenberg’s tonal experimentation, highlighting key compositions that mark this radical departure.

Early Tonal Works

Schoenberg’s early compositions adhered strictly to tonality, with each piece centered around a specific key and tone. Notable examples include his Second String Quartet (1907–08), where the transcendence of tonality begins to manifest. A significant innovation in this work is the incorporation of a vocal part, symbolically expressed through Stefan George’s words in the Finale, “Ich fühle Luft von anderen Planeten” (“I feel air from another planet”).

Atonal Breakthrough

On February 19, 1909, Schoenberg completed his Opus 11, a set of three piano pieces that completely discarded traditional tonal organization. These groundbreaking atonal compositions, also termed “pantonal” by Schoenberg, allowed for unrestricted harmonic and melodic combinations. Works like the Five Orchestral Pieces, Op. 16 (1909), and the monodrama Erwartung, Op. 17 (1924), showcased Schoenberg’s departure from tonality’s constraints.

The 12-Tone Method

In 1921, Schoenberg introduced the 12-tone method, a revolutionary composition technique. This method utilized a series of 12 different tones, allowing for various transformations such as inversion, retrograde, and transposition. Despite initial skepticism, Schoenberg’s opera Moses und Aron (begun in 1930) demonstrated the method’s power, marking a pinnacle in his creative achievements.

Later Works and Return to Tonal Elements

Throughout his life, Schoenberg continued to employ the 12-tone method, yet occasionally reverted to traditional tonality. Notable examples include the Suite for String Orchestra (1934) and the Variations on a Recitative for Organ, Op. 40 (1940). Schoenberg maintained that “There is still much good music to be written in C major,” showcasing his versatility.

Q&A Section

Q1: What prompted Schoenberg’s shift away from tonality?

A1: Schoenberg’s complex harmonies and melodies led to a diminished emphasis on tonality. The desire for unexplored musical territories drove him to transcend traditional tonal constraints.

Q2: How did the 12-tone method impact Schoenberg’s compositions?

A2: The 12-tone method provided Schoenberg with a structured yet flexible framework. It became a tool for unifying his compositions, evident in masterpieces like Moses und Aron.

Q3: Did Schoenberg face opposition to his innovative techniques?

A3: Yes, the introduction of atonality and the 12-tone method faced considerable opposition. However, over time, Schoenberg gained recognition for his groundbreaking contributions to 20th-century music.

Conclusion

Arnold Schoenberg’s journey from tonality to atonality and the establishment of the 12-tone method marked a paradigm shift in classical music. His innovative approach continues to influence composers, leaving an indelible legacy in the evolution of musical expression.